One of the most depressing, pessimistic, negative and plain old unappealing books I have ever read is Barbara Ehrenreich's Nickel and Dimed. Ms. Ehrenreich goes "undercover" as an entry level worker, and reports how incredibly difficult it is for people at the lower rungs to get by.
While I would never argue that people who earn hourly wages at Wal-Mart, fill orders at Wendy's or clean rooms at Hampton Inn don't have serious struggles, Ms. Ehrenreich's book was a joke. Part of her undercover stint took place in my hometown, Minneapolis. Thus, it was easy to see that the author didn't really want to be successful. She never tried to improve her positions, get superior housing, bargain for better anything at all. She was surly and rude to most with whom she met - be it co-workers, superiors or clerks where she was trying to find decent but inexpensive housing. Worst of all - she didn't like pet birds! Can you imagine...
In any case, today I read the flip side of this embodiment of suffering: Homeless in South Carolina. Here, a young man tries an experiment of starting out with virtually nothing; $25 and the clothes on his body. Yet, despite having almost nothing whatsoever, this young man tells a story of hard work and hope, resulting in vindication, success and savings.
During his first 70 days in Charleston, Shepard lived in a shelter and received food stamps. He also made new friends, finding work as a day laborer, which led to a steady job with a moving company.
Ten months into the experiment, he decided to quit after learning of an illness in his family. But by then he had moved into an apartment, bought a pickup truck, and had saved close to $5,000.
The effort, he says, was inspired after reading "Nickel and Dimed," in which author Barbara Ehrenreich takes on a series of low-paying jobs. Unlike Ms. Ehrenreich, who chronicled the difficulty of advancing beyond the ranks of the working poor, Shepard found he was able to successfully climb out of his self-imposed poverty.
He tells his story in "Scratch Beginnings: Me, $25, and the Search for the American Dream." The book, he says, is a testament to what ordinary Americans can achieve.
People who get "Nickel and Dimed" should burn it as being dangerous. Instead, they should read these words:
Would your project have changed if you'd had child-care payments or been required to report to a probation officer? Wouldn't that have made it much harder?
The question isn't whether I would have been able to succeed. I think it's the attitude that I take in: "I've got child care. I've got a probation officer. I've got all these bills. Now what am I going to do? Am I going to continue to go out to eat and put rims on my Cadillac? Or am I going to make some things happen in my life...?" One guy, who arrived [at the shelter] on a Tuesday had been hit by a car on [the previous] Friday by a drunk driver. He was in a wheelchair. He was totally out of it. He was at the shelter. And I said, "Dude, your life is completely changed." And he said, "Yeah, you're right, but I'm getting the heck out of here." Then there was this other guy who could walk and everything was good in his life, but he was just kind of bumming around, begging on the street corner. To see the attitudes along the way, that is what my story is about.
You made it out of the shelter, got a job, and opened a bank account. Did you meet other people who had similar experiences?
Oh, absolutely. We don't need "Scratch Beginnings" to know that millions of Americans are creating a life for themselves from nothing.... Just as millions of Americans are not getting by. There are both ends of the spectrum.
To meet that guy [in the wheelchair] at the shelter, [makes you wonder] 'Can he get out and go to college and become a doctor?' Maybe, maybe not. I think he can set goals..... You can use your talents. That's why, from the beginning, I set very realistic goals: $2,500, a job, car. This isn't a "rags-to-riches million-dollar" story. This is very realistic. I truly believe, based on what I saw at the shelter ...that anyone can do that.
Success is achieved by doing what you need to do to be successful - and by believing that you can achieve and do better. It is achieved by doing as well as you can, one day at a time.
"Success is achieved by doing what you need to do to be successful - and by believing that you can achieve and do better. It is achieved by doing as well as you can, one day at a time."
Immigrants, legal and otherwise, prove it all the time.
Posted by: James Ament | Saturday, February 16, 2008 at 04:13 PM
Uh, yeah. Young white guy, right? Could get blue-collar work? Of *course* he got ahead. There are areas of the country trying to get more women into blue-collar work, but most of what we qualify for we have to have training to get into, and that takes time. And it isn't available everywhere.
You find me a woman of any race and put her in that exact same situation and, hey, throw in some kids while you're at it, and see how well she does with a "good attitude." Then maybe you'll have a point.
Nobody ever really *gets* a job. It has to be given to them, whether or not they have earned it. Nobody ever *gets* pay--it has to be given to them, and the employer gets to decide how much. And if you don't factor in gender, racial, family status, and age discrimination, of course you're going to get a slanted picture of what it takes to succeed from nothing. Like it or not you can't walk through a wall. What you *think* does not alter reality. A good attitude IS important, if only to preserve a person's basic sanity, but thoughts by themselves do nothing material.
Anyway, I thought you were for free speech. What's all this book-burning talk, then?
Posted by: somebody | Tuesday, February 19, 2008 at 02:06 PM